- 1
Pros and cons of dijskatra's and Prim's algorithm
2 Réponses
+ 6
Dijkstra's Algorithm
PRO
1)Uninformed algorithm
Dijkstra is an uninformed algorithm. This means that it does not need to know the target node beforehand. For this reason it's optimal in cases where you don't have any prior knowledge of the graph when you cannot estimate the distance between each node and the target.
2)Good when you have multiple target nodes
Since Dijkstra picks edges with the smallest cost at each step it usually covers a large area of the graph. This is especially useful when you have multiple target nodes but you don't know which one is the closest.
CON
Fails for negative edge weights
If we take for example 3 Nodes (A, B and C) where they form an undirected graph with edges: AB = 3, AC = 4, BC=-2, the optimal path from A to C costs 1 and the optimal path from A to B costs 2. If we apply Dijkstra's algorithm: starting from A it will first examine B because it is the closest node. and will assign a cost of 3 to it and therefore mark it closed which means that its cost will never be reevaluated. This means that Dijkstra's cannot evaluate negative edge weights.
+ 1
Prim's algorithm
Advantages
Simple
Disadvantages
Time taken to check for smallest weight arc makes it slow for large numbers of nodes
Difficult to program, though it can be programmed in matrix form.